Kingdoms, Monasteries and Mosques
I went to see 'The Kingdom of Heaven' at the cinema last night. It starred Orlando Bloom (nice), but he looked uncannily like my younger brother in this film (off-putting). It brought home to me the ease at which we enter war and the sheer insanity of it. I'm not going to write an entire review of the film, nor am I going to write about the Crusades (I would only betray my ignorance). There was something else that struck me - not the politicking between kings and rulers, but rather the situation of ordinary people of whatever religion - mere pawns in a game of political chess, disposed of carelessly in senseless acts of war designed to promote one religion or one culture above another.
I am fortunate enough not to have witnessed a great deal of violence. (Yes, even growing up in Northern Ireland, its not something I've really experienced witnessed personally.) However, it is my conviction that the only way for peace in Northern Ireland is for Catholic and Protestant communities to meet one another, engage freely and openly with one another and respect the traditions of the other. On Tuesday night, a series entitled 'The Monastery' began on BBC2. (Apologies to non-UK readers). This is high quality reality TV (seriously). A group of men of various backgrounds have entered a Benedictine monastery for 40 days and the program is following their experiences.
One character, Gary, stood out. He is a fellow Northern Irisher, was formerly involved in the UDA (a paramilitary group) and spent much of his life in prison. Yet, more than any of the other characters - he was spoken of the acceptance and warmth he has experienced amongst the monks. The experience seems, to me anyway, to have had a unique impact on him compared with the others. I wonder, if entering into a Catholic monastery has something to do with it. When welcomed by another, especially if that other is someone or something we have previously had misconceptions about or are alien to, there can be a special appreciation of hospitality and sense of welcome.
I am reminded of an experience I had last summer on an interfaith walk for peace. The walk, which is taking place again this year on June 12th in Southampton should anyone care to join us, is a walking tour of various places of worship in Southampton - from the Hindu temple, to the mosque, to the church and the synagogue. It was also where I happily found the Quakers for the first time. As is typical of me and those who came with me, we arrived slightly late having spent more time than we had predicted finding a suitable parking space and so were somewhat disorganised and dishevelled. New to interfaith meanderings, I entirely forgot to bring something with me to cover my head. Thankfully, where it was necessary, head-coverings were provided. However, when we arrived in the mosque nothing was provided. Fancying myself as rather culturally aware, I approached one of the men at the door and asked if they had anything I could cover my head with. He ushered me into the room saying that it didn't matter.
There was something special to be welcomed as I was, uncovered, into another's sacred place. The mosque was special for some reason. Sitting on the soft carpet, listing to the Qu'ran sung in Arabic, I felt a special peace and the atmosphere felt more hospitable to me than anywhere else. It is in places like this that we make peace with one another, and places like this where perhaps, peace can begin on a broader scale. As we recognise and embrace our shared humanity, and learn to bow our heads (or cover them), respecting the religion of another, perhaps we can learn to live together, valuing the freedom of others and the value of their religion as much as we value our own freedom and our own faith.
Although I have not witnessed much in the way of religious violence, I have witnessed a more subtle form of violence - that of devaluing the faith or religion of another. In Northern Ireland, many protestants believe Roman Catholics are off a different religion, and some are want to ensure that everyone knows that this other religion is false. It is the same in other places - I've sat through prayer meetings where earnest Christians have prayed for the salvation of Muslims. By this they don't been liberation and peace for Islamic communities - they often mean that they want Muslims to become Christians. This too is fanaticism. Just as in the past, the temple in Jerusalem was jostled over and trampled over by those claiming it as their own, so today, true religion, true faith is trampled over by those claiming the whole truth for themselves.
It is only in learning, respecting and embracing that we can find peace. Perhaps friendship and hospitality can overcome the madness of fanatics.
Were there worlds beyond which they could never touch, or did all that is possible enter their consciousness? They could not tell. . . . Perhaps life is a mystery, not a muddle. . . . Perhaps the hundred Indias which fuss and squabble so tiresomely are one, and the universe they mirror is one. They had not the apparatus for judging. -EM FORSTER, A PASSAGE TO INDIA


9 Comments:
I stumbled across a magazine Ken sent me a few monthes ago, from his trip over to the USA to see you. It's a disturbing publication, by a fairly reactionary free Church denomination (I believe this one). And the special theme was Islam vs Catholicism, proceeding to detail all the ills of each of them, and how they were going to clash, for the good protestant reader.
Such a shame, that willful predjudice and malignant ignorance can be so easy. And yet there is hope, not least in the witness of history. For every former devastating purge of Spain's Jews & Muslims, we have a fomer Indian society where Abrahamic faiths were once able to live in commonality with Hinduism.
I think one of the silliest things I've heard happen over here is the following phonecall my mum received in her work one day before Christmas (she works for the head of primary school in the SEELB):
Man: "Hello, my child attends a protestant school. We are strong protestants. I have discovered the school has Catholic idols in it. Could you please have them removed. Immediately."
Her: (slightly frightened as he sounded like he had a collection of baseball bats and ate little PAs for breakfast and shocked - it was a well known protestant school) "Well, what is it?"
Man: "A Christmas tree"
Her: "A Christmas tree?! What is wrong with a Christmas tree?"
Man: "As the name indicates Christmas in the Mass of Christ. It is a Catholic celebration and we do not celebrate it. Will the tree be removed?"
Her: "Hold on, I'll just get my boss.."
I thought that was rather appalling...
Rachxx
WHAT?!?!? All these years and my grandmother has had a Catholic idol in her house...just wait til I tell my Orangeman uncle. Oh this is not gonna be pretty!
Rach, I don't know whether to laugh or cry :S
Ruthie
i've never heard anything quite as silly as christmas trees being slated, although things do get pretty odd around here as well...really good post ruthie, i wish there was more openess to inter faith gatherings, i think religions can learn from each other, as you said.
Oh I've heard Christmas trees get slated before, but for being pagan, not Catholic ;)
Mary - sometimes, I think we need to start where our own communities are at. In Northern Ireland, those who mix freely with 'the other side', are the true peacemakers, and are probably taking a more radical approach than the cosy English gatherings over tea, curry and cake. Although I have to say, mixing in a multi-faith context is definately more fun :D! I doubt there's much of that in Northern Ireland, mainly because there isn't a large multi-faith or multi-racial community over there.
Mind you, this may be changing. I did here something tragic/funny the other day. My aunt's partner's mum was at a multi-racial gathering where there were Indians and Africans cooking food. She described them both as 'foreigners', the Africans as 'the darker ones' and the Indians as the 'lighter ones'. But did say that the food was lovely.
Mind you my gran did go on a rant about refugees a while ago, and I pointed out that one of my best friends who she has met several times comes from a refugee family. 'Ah, but that's different, she's such a nice girl.'
You gotta laugh :D!
Ruthie
Hi Ruthie...
We are all, all refugees from some where, some time, some thing, all on the road from pain towards hope...
I needed a nice warm bit of Christianity, thanks. I have seen too much in the past five decades, much to much, and I agree, that more than anything, we all need to sit and talk and learn each other's histories. The same histories make for different conclusions, and they will never be resolved as a single set of conclusions, but love takes understanding of each other's sense of history to forgive and move forward together, be it South Africa, our dear tortured Ireland, or a few Friends at odds.
You gave me a warm smile today,
A Place to rest
As the day crawls out another night crawls in.
Time neither moves nor dies
It's the time of day when the lark sings
The black of night with the curlew cries
There's rain on the wind, the tears of spirits
The clink of the key on iron is near
A shuttling train passes by on rail
There's more than God for man to fear.
Towards where the evening crow would fly, my thoughts lie
And like ships in the night they blindly sail
Blown by a thought - that breaks the heart -
of Forty women in Armagh jail
Oh! and I wish I were with the gentle folk
Around a heartened fire wither the fairies dance unseen,
Away from the black devils of H- - Block hell
Who torture my heart and haunt my dream
I would gladly rest where the whin bush grow,
Beneath the rocks where the linnets sing,
In Carnmoney Graveyard 'neith its hill,
Fearing not what day would bring
Bobby Sands, MP. Died on hunger strike, May 5, 1981
Talking... this post has been so much on my mind.
Without talking, deep honest talking, we can't have clearness, without clearness, we can't have understanding, without understanding forgiveness, without forgiveness, we can't have peace.
War is about believable assumptions carried to the extreme, in almost every case they turn out to be wrong in the end.
My dear late friend Sally wrote, just before she died, "Christian forgiveness is not saying a bad thing did not happen, or putting a good name on a bad thing, but not letting it get in the way of the relationship."
Oh to have peace in the world, and peace in my life.
lor
Can we learn something about inter-faith relationships from Sally's approach to christian forgiveness?
Not saying that differences don't exist, not pretending the differences don't matter, not even asserting that different ways must always all be right, but not letting these differences get in the way of the relationship either.
You can believe in the rightness of your own faith and hope that others might come to share it, without hating or despising those who believe differently. There is always something to learn from others -- even if, like early druids and their human sacrifices, it's sometimes a horrible warning!
Hiya ##NAME##, just thought I'd say great post titled ##TITLE##. I'm looking for ##LINK## and I ended up here accidentally but I will make sure I return soon. Looking for in addition will keep me busy for a few hours.
Post a Comment
<< Home